by Jason Osiason

Civil War presents a dystopian America fractured by internal conflict. The story follows Lee (an on-the-nose reference to famed war photographer Lee Miller), a photojournalist played by Kirsten Dunst, as she navigates a dangerous and divided nation. Alongside her, the film explores the lives of civilians and soldiers caught in the turmoil, highlighting their struggles for survival and resistance. Dunst’s performance is surprisingly serviceable given her skillset but lacks depth due to Garland’s writing. The narrative weaves through various characters, including Nick Offerman’s inspired portrayal of the President, which avoids the pitfalls of stunt casting as it mimics, but is not a pure imitation of Donald Trump.

Cailee Spaeny of Priscilla fame shows promise as a performer as Jessie, a young activist fighting for justice, adding some nuance to the otherwise one-dimensional cast. Stephen McKinley Henderson also delivers a standout performance as Sammy, a character who brings the film’s only rich, rewarding portrayal, still seeking his perfect role but gaining more recognition.

Wagner Moura’s Joel, a disillusioned former soldier, is disappointingly flat, failing to convey the necessary intensity. In stark contrast, Jesse Plemons delivers a chillingly eerie performance in a brief but unforgettable role, featuring one of the year’s most frightening sequences. His character, despite limited screen time, leaves a lasting impact.

The film’s climax, featuring the White House being invaded by infantry, delivers visually but lacks the narrative punch needed for a powerful conclusion. Alex Garland’s direction is superior, elevating the film above its weak plot and underdeveloped stakes.

Overall, Civil War is a mixed bag. It serves as an excellent satirical commentary on America’s potential future, offering a chilling message about the inevitable trajectory the country may be headed. Despite its narrative flaws, the film’s technical achievements and occasional standout performances make it a thought-provoking watch. Ultimately, Civil War serves as both a warning and a wake-up call, urging viewers to reflect on the possible consequences of what lies ahead for us. [C+]